“Palimpsest” by Caleb Ludwick

Patty Paine

Dad is six foot six, taller than he looked on television, with a too-much mouth and thrilling hair. For months after his show was cancelled, he still cut a figure down on Michigan Ave, where pasty, bone-tired, Midwestern ladies would stop him to ask for a photo, clinging to his son Ariel’s wrist and warbling, “How striking he was, in his day.” But then his shoulders would curl like dry leaves and he’d be abruptly thin in his sweatshirt, eyes too watery to be handsome, as if the studio cameras had fed something deep and ravenous, and once they were gone, so was a piece of him. He stopped wearing pancake and stopped leaving the house.

Late July puddles on the asphalt. An AC unit gasps from the window, churning out nothing but the stink of hot plastic. Daylight from the window throws uneven patches across the table: scrap clippings in loose piles, a bundle of manila envelopes leaning against a glass jar of red markers. Dad’s little Datsun sits in the driveway: pewter-colored, nowhere close to being paid off, ambitiously hitched to a boat trailer. The sedan hunches under the weight, its rear axle bowed. And on the trailer: the johnboat. A torn green tarp hangs like seaweed from its battered bow. The hull is gashed open near the stern, where the motor used to be: a face missing its jaw.

But Ariel knows the hull is just metal; you could patch it if you had the time. It’s the story wrapped around it that cuts deeper, once someone believes it.

When the reporter shows up—a student with only a Moleskine and her smartphone—Dad motions her to the kitchen table. He is wearing his old tie, badly creased, the knot too fat.

“I’m usually the one asking questions,” he says. “Did you ever watch Midday with Murphy?”

She smiles and shakes her head.

“Well, I know all the tricks, my dear,” he chuckles. “You won’t get anything past me.”

Every anecdote carries rehearsal marks, tiny pauses, the same flick of the eyes reading a teleprompter before a punch line. Ariel knows his pattern: pare the facts flat, lay them one atop another so they pass for a single surface.

“That looks painful. Does it hurt?” the reporter asks Ariel.

“Son, she’s talking to you.” He turns overly formal. “He’s not used to the spotlight. But it’s your show now, Ariel.”

“His name is Ariel?”

“His mother chose it. Big Disney fan.”

Chin up, Ariel thinks. He sits down at the table so she can get a good look at his hurt arm. On the mend, tucked snug in its sling, like it knows exactly how every detail should be told.

The girl looks away, smoothing her hair, glancing at her notes for where to begin. “So, Ariel. How long were you adrift?”

“Hours,” Dad cuts in, “but I don’t know if he was on the water the whole time. He doesn’t like to talk about it.”

“Too triggering?” she asks, tilting her head. Careful, like someone reaching through a fence to a strange dog.

“Oh, he’s not scared,” Dad says. “He’s not the type.”

Ariel had watched for years as the city turned a starry gaze to Dad, soaking up the bluster, the theater. But he also saw what was left behind. The worn-out stories, needing a new cue card. So, he tells himself, he will give him one. But really, what Ariel wants shifts every time he looks at Dad: Sometimes he wants him worried, that baffling certainty rattled. Sometimes Ariel wants him to look around the room, at their life, with the look he only gave to Camera Two.

After a minute, Dad says, “Ariel, why don’t you grab the civil complaint? I want our friend here to have all the facts. So those shitweasels down at Inland Marine are held accountable. What if their big tanks, full of God knows what—sulfuric acid, benzene, methanol—had ruptured and spilled all over my boy?”

Ariel knows the file folder Dad wants and crosses the kitchen to get it. Dad has become a documentarian in his retirement boredom, even before the accident. Staying up late, cutting articles from newspapers or printing pages off the web, filing and labeling every mention of his old television crew, circling their names in red ink.

It’s only been two days since Ariel was injured, and even before he called the lawyers, Dad had everything ready: drone shots of a tank boat’s hull, harbor schedules, photos of the wrecked johnboat. He packaged it all up and emailed it to every local journalist he had ever met. Ariel watched him work through his old contacts, growing more animated with every message, as if the accident had given him a reason to be somebody again. His old station, ABC 7, passed, as did the morning news channels and the Trib. And everyone else, until the Loyola Phoenix, the university paper, said they were curious. That they would send a student reporter to get the details, someone who knew enough about maritime law to ask the right questions.

“The boat was Ariel’s sixteenth birthday present,” Dad says, but it wasn’t. It was a parting gift from the network, an aluminum punchline about retirement and fishing. Dad hated fishing almost as much as the idea of being retired, so he let his son take the boat out and never asked for it back.

“All we need is an itty bit of publicity,” he said. “An article we can show the judge, to let those bastards know they don’t own the port.”

The reporter taps her pen on the notebook. Ariel hasn’t looked at her, not really, until now, and he sees she’s quite attractive. Korean maybe, or Japanese. Or Filipino. Or Thai. Or Malaysian. He isn’t sure how to tell.

He follows her eyes around the room: the photos of Dad with that country singer with the palm straw hat, with that eight-time Pro Bowler, with a TV chef at her restaurant out by Opryland. Dad always with his signature red umbrella and his noon-bright smile.

“Excuse me. What do you want?” Ariel asks her quietly.

“Honestly, all I want is 500 words and to catch the ferry home before dark.” She leans forward. “But you, Ariel. What do you want?”

Ariel had been waiting for those four words. Now that she’d said them, he wasn’t sure how to answer.

Of course, if Ariel says what he wants, he has to make his dad pay attention. For him to hear, in order to see.

“I’ve been thinking about that,” Ariel says.

“Is it just to be photographed?” she asks.

“Because sometimes—” Ariel stops. The reporter isn’t supposed to interrupt him. He wasn’t prepared to answer unknown questions. He thought she’d only take notes then shoot him crouched beside the mangled hull or staring into the middle distance out over the water.

“Tell her about the big boat, son. The big wake,” Dad says, trying to come back to the soundbite.

She glances at the door, as if gauging how much longer she has to play along. “So you wanted to disappear?” she asks.

“I told you, he’s not the type to tuck tail.”

“I’m not saying he’s scared. Maybe he’s just sixteen.”

Ariel wonders how this would go differently if his father wasn’t here. Maybe he could take the reporter’s hand and lead her through the story, show her the evidence. He wonders how she might describe him to her friends later, or to her editor. Whether she might think of Ariel when another man locks up the office and asks her back to his place. Whether she might ever say, “There was this guy—” and mean him.

“Was there really a tank boat at all?” she whispers. “Did you make it up?”

​​There’s no real bite in her words. More like she is checking that everyone is still reading from the same page.

“It’s not like that,” Ariel says.

Dad hadn’t heard him tell it before, not all of it. The lawyers got the baseline version, stripped for parts, so he knew the broad strokes: the ship, the sling, the bent hull, but not the part where he describes being alone, with the water closing over his head.

Ariel takes a deep breath and says, “I was a quarter mile from Navy Pier. The lake was quiet, barely a ripple. And then a giant freighter came out of nowhere. Steel gray, no name on the hull, no flag. The big twin chemical tanks pulled it low in the water. I waved my arms, but they didn’t even slow down.”

He pauses while the student writes something down.

“The wake behind the boat was gigantic, like dynamite under the surface. It swamped me, flipped me sideways. The motor tore off like tin foil.”

“Sheesh,” she says.

“Those shipping companies don’t log near misses,” Dad says. “But ask anyone down at the Harbor Master. It’s a known thing.”

“I hit the water like a rock,” Ariel says. “Woke up under the hull. I couldn’t tell if it was night or day.”

At first, he didn’t notice Dad looking up, slowly. “You were knocked unconscious? In the water?”

His face goes to chalk, as if ink from the marker was leaking from his hand, blood draining out of his body through the felt tip onto the paper.

Ariel shifts in his chair. He looks down at his arm, adjusting the sling even though it hasn’t moved. For a moment, he can’t quite meet his father’s eyes.

“That’s right, Dad. Dead in the water.”

“Okay, Ariel,” the reporter says.

Dad’s eyes flick from the reporter to his son and back again, frightened, fierce, and glistening. Ariel had only ever seen this look once before. Dad kneeling when Ariel busted his lip on the driveway, dabbing it with his tie, not caring that he was late for the show. He grips Ariel’s uninjured arm now. Ariel feels it all the way into his torso, squeezing his lungs, his heart. Not hard, just a firm and unyielding pressure.

“You didn’t tell me that part, son. You said that, but for your shoulder, you were okay.”

“I am, Dad. I am,” Ariel says and stands up to come around behind him. He places his hands on his father’s shoulders. They feel like bundled wires beneath the dress shirt. Up close, Ariel can see that the knot of his tie is too tight, creasing the skin under his chin. Tiny, snowy flakes caught in the weave of his button-down. Ariel brushes them away.

“Dad, you should be in the picture, too,” he says.

“You think so?” Dad asks, his voice small.

“Sure, why not?” the reporter says, and Ariel feels him rise, like a prizefighter called back into the ring for one more round.

“Feel free to use anything with me in it.” He gives a thumbs up. “Might help sell some papers.”

She takes the shot. And in the flash, Ariel doesn’t care that she hasn’t asked any questions, nothing about timetables, radar, AIS data. Or how the hell he didn’t notice a two-hundred-foot boat on a quiet harbor until it ran him down. He doesn’t care what she prints or doesn’t, what she posts so it can get a few clicks before it vanishes into the ether. He just wants her to go. Because then he could fix in his mind the way Dad looked at him. Like Ariel had given back something he had lost, without realizing that he might have to take it away again, so he can give it back again.

When he wakes up, Ariel doesn’t look at the clock. Out in the kitchen, Dad is asleep with his head on his forearm, still holding the pen. In his shaky scrawl, Ariel sees that he has written, palimpsest, over the newspaper columns: My son was dead, and is alive again; he was lost and is found.

Ariel ducks out the side door. Unhooks the boat trailer. As always, the car smells like aftershave and cigars. The streetlamps are still on, the city washed clean by night crews. He passes boutiques and galleries with shadow figures in the windows.

Then he hits the curb and is up onto the sidewalk. The tires whimper, the car quakes. He plows over a utility box. One wheel well scrapes hard against concrete, but he steers steady down the sidewalk, speeding up. Bashes against a telephone pole and keeps going. Somewhere in the background, alarms are blaring. A stack of newspapers, tied at a corner, bursts under the tires, gray sheets chasing the car down the block. A man on the corner drops his coffee, swearing and giving Ariel the finger. Somewhere closer now, a siren rises, warping around buildings. Off the back bumper, the boat hitch rattles like a broken arm.

Ariel thinks of the johnboat, propped on its trailer like a carcass. And of Dad, brittle and grasping his hand under the table, holding himself together for one more photograph. Imagining his face, the unscripted words. You could have been hurt.

✶✶✶✶

Beginning his career as a carpenter, Caleb Ludwick has since won Fractured Literary’s 2025 OPEN Prize, been selected for publication in The Appalachian Review and The Lindenwood Review, and been invited to the Yale Writers’ Workshop and Sewanee Writers’ Conference (Tennessee Williams Scholar). His debut collection of stories, The First Time She Fell, was a Foreword Review finalist for Independent Press Book of the Year.

Patty Paine is the author of Grief & Other Animals, The Sounding Machine, and three chapbooks. Her writing and visual work have appeared in Blackbird, The Denver Quarterly, Gulf Stream, Waxwing, Analog Forever, Lomography, The South Dakota Review, and other publications. She is the founding editor of Diode Poetry Journal and Diode Editions and is Director of Liberal Arts & Sciences at VCUarts Qatar.

✶

Whenever possible, we link book titles to Bookshop.org, an independent bookselling site. As a Bookshop affiliate, Another Chicago Magazine earns a small percentage from qualifying purchases.